Apple’s patent victory is a victory for competition
Apple resounding patent victory over Samsung in a California courtroom last Friday is a blow to the competition, which now won be able copy Apple technology. But it is a win for competition. It will force everyone to think harder about turning moncler outlet woodbury the unimaginable into the normal. It a very moncler outlets uk tangled area of IP that in the modern day tech industry has Official Moncler Outlet been a life cheap moncler jackets support system (think Kodak) and a means of protecting oneself against patent trolls (like that guy who tried to sue the World Wide Web). Patent troves, in the astute description of buy moncler jackets toronto technologist Andy Baio, have also been weaponized in perverted campaigns to stifle innovation.
moncler outlet Apple and Samsung are duking it out all over the world some 50 lawsuits in about 10 moncler jackets canada countries, by one reckoning in a sort of forever war. Samsung got a cheap moncler jackets wholesale favorable moncler coats for men ruling just days before in a South Korean court. But the marquee case was the one in San Jose, California, where a jury found that Samsung had violated six of the seven patents Apple sought to defend three software and three design cheap moncler coats for women and awarded the company $1.05 billion.
buy moncler jackets The conventional wisdom is that a victory like this for a company like Apple is bad for consumers because it gives a virtual monopoly even more marketplace power.
monlcer down jackets Dan Gimor, director of the Knight Center for Digital Media Entrepreneurship at Arizona State University Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication and nobody fool presents this case as clearly as I have seen:
cheap moncler coats for women moncler sale e likely to see moncler jackets mens a ban on many mobile devices from Samsung and other moncler outlet location manufacturers in the wake of this case, as moncler outlet uk an cheap moncler emboldened Apple tries to create an unprecedented monopoly. If so, the ultimate loser will be competition moncler jackets cheap in the technology marketplace, with even more power moncler outlet usa accruing to a company that already has too much.
cheap moncler outlet Leave aside the California jury wisdom or the possibility the outcome will be reversed on appeal. Leave aside how you feel about the iPhone. Leave aside how you feel about Apple, whose Microsoft like imperiousness was more charming when it was moncler outlet mall a minor underdog and Moncler Factory Outlet not bigger than Microsoft. Leave aside how much Apple deep hatred of Google related to Android, the market moncler jackets toronto leading moncler outlets usa mobile operating system that moncler coats for kids powers Samsung and many other phones, may be driving this blood feud.
cheap moncler coats We tech consumers are interested in price, and in the near term, tablets and smartphones could be more expensive because of license fees and the huge cost of patent litigation added to moncler coats for cheap the cost of the electronics we buy. And there may also be less choice for a while.
moncler sale outlet But we have a deeper vested interest in the leveling power that comes from true competition, even if it costs a moncler jackets for women little more to get there. It not about rewarding the originator of an idea. It about challenging everyone else to come up with a better one. We should be for moncler outlet store things that punish technological complacency and that protect conditions for innovation, not take a rooting interest in which companies are winning and which are losing (Pandodaily Farhad Manjoo makes a great case that copying paid off handsomely for Samsung revenue of about $25 million from the infringing handsets, versus a cost of litigation of about $3 billion).
moncler outlet sale Extending the status moncler jacket online quo womens moncler jackets as in making more phones like iPhones may have made things cheaper, but it wasn going to inspire innovation or cultivate the Next Great Thing. It the difference between competing in the marketplace and competing in the marketplace of ideas: There a narrow advantage to us in the former and an incalculable one in the latter.
cheap moncler jackets Take a look at one of the patents Apple successfully defended. Apple strict enforcement of scroll which alerts you to the moncler outlet online of a by snapping it back to fill the screen would mean that Android phones can have it. Owners of anything but an iPhone would be denied a very obvious and very handy feature without feedback, you might just think that discount moncler jackets the page has stopped loading, which happens quite a lot. This sort of animation adds character and moncler jacket outlet makes a smartphone more intuitive. It not a killer app but, like power steering, maybe should be on every car once it invented.
moncler mens jackets It came into being because 2018 moncler some smart person or team thought it up to address a user interface shortcoming that nobody else had given much attention to, or that hadn been solved as well. Apple took a chance on it (and dozens of other big and little original ideas) and struck gold with the iPhone and its operating system.
Whether or not you believe Apple should moncler chicago even be moncler outlet kids in a position to own it is irrelevant. By borrowing so heavily, Apple competitors aren on the road to inventing anything that could change everything. They aren competing. They just moncler outlet canada offering modestly differentiated alternatives of an idea moncler jackets on sale of a smartphone that has already caught on.
cheap moncler Competitors need to identify flaws the other guy hasn and boldly moncler jackets kids pursue solutions. Apple does this, not so much by inventing but by reimagining: There were music players before the iPod, desktop computers before the iMac, smartphones before the iPhone, tablets before the iPad. But they all had missing ingredients Apple didn pluck off someone else shelf.
moncler sale So powerful is Apple moncler outlet ny reputation for radically improving on things that have been tried that we are pining to see what its vision https://www.newmoncleroutlet.com for a TV set might be (in an era when the best TV set you have is your smartphone or tablet), and ponder how it would moncler outlet online store have designed a car.
moncler outlet store Where is Apple competition?
The irony is that Samsung has already come up with a suitable alternative to bounce back scroll, the New York Times reports: a blue glow when you reach the bottom of a page. Sounds cool. Maybe even cooler.
moncler outlet online Even more ironic: Patents complicate progress but are more like annoying speed bumps than insurmountable walls. this industry, patents are not a clean weapon to moncler outlet stop others, Silicon Valley consultant and former IBM IP Strategy VP Kevin G. Rivette told the Times. technology, like water, will find its way around impediments.
Sterne Agee analyst Shaw Wu also argues as much. In telling Reuters that the entire Android universe moncler jackets men may now have to consider something different Wu is postulating that there always is something different to do.
What moncler coats outlet good for a competitor isn necessarily what good for competition. Necessity, the old saying goes, is the mother of invention. Discount Moncler Coats Competition slows when competitors sample, when they rely too heavily on the breakthroughs of others.
It no accident that every smartphone now looks a lot like the iPhone (and none did before the iPhone). But it is a crying shame. Invent something, already.